I rated it a 5/5 because it is what it is... extremely light and comfortable. Great harness if you're not putting much stress on it. Your cant have everything, so if you want a light, functional, ''barely even notice its there'' harness... this is a 5/5 in my book. Great for alpine and pack hipbelts, gear loops hang below my packs hipbelt and there are no pressure points because the loops are hung low and flush. If you're going to put a fair amount of stress falling, hanging, or sitting; a more cushy harness would be a better option. The Adjama's strength is in the thin outlining material, can put a fair amount of stress on your waist where that meets your body.