If this is what I think I climbed, I would give it a 6b+. It is quite long, and the crux is very tricky. Eagle Wall reminds me a lot of the Gunks - blocky rock, cracks, and everything seems to be capped by a killer roof at the top. I toproped this clean (maybe a rest at the crux?), but when I tried to lead it, it was really much more difficult. The crux is beautiful, but daunting. After 10 minutes of hanging, I finally got over it though. I would definitely climb this again.