This was my first outdoor climb! I have been climbing inside for a while now. The guidebook by Tom Slater lists this as a 5.6, which sounds more right to me. Fun, short and easy (enough) climb. Top Roped. Beautiful scenery!
This is no where near a 5.4. Not a good first lead in any universe. I TR soloed it. Good anchor and easy access. Otherwise a horrible climb. The first bolt is way too high for a first lead, and the holds are tiny for an 8, let alone a 4. There are a couple of fun moves, but it would be irresponsible to put a new leader on this one. Whoever rated these hasn't been on a 5.6 anywhere else in the states.