Yes, I gave the Evo's a 5 rating. The shoes are wicked awesome. I started climbing indoors using the shoes at the gym. I was getting better and so I decided to buy myself my own set of shoes. I tried out a few pairs and then found the Evos. I tried them on and they fit very snug, and it might be because I had never purchased a pair of climbing shoes, but I didn't notice how loose the heel was on me. Granted, I do have very flat feet, which could prevent me from wearing them too well. I'm rambling, but anyway, this shoe has proven to be a great asset to my climbing(I've been indoors and outdoors with them now). I've conquered almost all of the routes I possibly can and now it might be myself that's holding the shoes back. Oh well, I guess I'll have to train harder. I'm now looking to buy a different pair of shoes for my arsenal, a size smaller even. Possibly the Pontas???